Explore the intriguing concept of strange loops in human cognition in this thought-provoking conference talk. Delve into a critical examination of Douglas Hofstadter's analogies between Kurt Gödel's First Incompleteness Theorem and consciousness. Investigate the potential limitations of using mathematical logic to explain mental phenomena. Analyze the concept of tangled hierarchies and their relevance to understanding the mind. Examine Escher's Drawing Hands as an example of an illusory loop. Unpack Hofstadter's ideas on symbols, self-symbols, and mental causation. Question the necessity of sophisticated metamathematics in explaining consciousness. Consider alternative perspectives on high-level phenomena and abstract causes in cognitive science. Reflect on the implications of these ideas for our understanding of the mind-body problem and the nature of consciousness.
Overview
Syllabus
Intro
G1 and Two Philosophy of Mind Applications
Two kinds of Tangled Hierarchies
Example of an Illusory Loop: Escher's Drawing Hands
The Basics of Hofstadter's Picture: Who Shoves Whom Inside The Cranium?
Symbols
The Self-Symbol
Revisiting The Strange Loop of Mental Causation
Why Gödel? Formal Systems and "Mental Systems"
An Intrinsically High-Level Phenomenon
Abstract Causes
Isn't Sophisticated Metamathematics Redundant?
The High-Level Perspective Lesson
A Way Out?
Final Thoughts
Taught by
Models of Consciousness Conferences
